Wednesday, May 9, 2012
Motorcycle Safety
Bikers, be Safe
It is always sad to see the injuries in motorcycle cases in our office, and although the person at fault in the accident is almost always the other driver, many times the calamity might have been avoided if the biker had taken an extra measure of defensive driving. Because of my concern for the safety of our motorcycle friends, from time to time I try to pass along a tip which can serve as a reminder. If this saves just one motorcyclist from injury, my effort will be well worth it.
Studies have shown that people who feel less vulnerable to injury have a tendency to take greater risks and to overcompensate for enhanced safety features thus leading to more injuries and fatalities.
The danger here is that a biker with a helmet and full protective gear might drive faster, take faster turns and be less careful of other traffic than bikers with no helmet and ordinary clothing. So being aware of this potential danger is the first step in avoiding it. By all means take advantage of all of the protection you feel comfortable with, but be aware that it is not a free pass for reckless driving.
Wednesday, May 2, 2012
Truck Safety Rules
Truck Safety Rules
Truck drivers and their employers carry a heavy responsibility to make sure that their big rigs do not pose a hazard to other vehicles on the highway. Unfortunately the pressures to make a profit or to increase the driver’s or operator’s income sometimes result in decisions which endanger the traveling public. Drivers are often tempted to push the limits of the rules, particularly in failing to observe the required rest requirements. Any truck driver who is on the road in a tired condition poses a serious hazard.
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration has promulgated new rules designed to increase highway safety. The updated rules provide:
• An 11-hour driving limit (unchanged) with a requirement of a 30-minute break before 8 consecutive hours of driving
• During the 34-hour “restart” or off duty time, there must be at least two consecutive nighttime periods lasting from 1:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m.
Although the agency has been criticized for its failure to adopt more stringent requirements, especially leaving the 11-hour limit rather than going to 10 hours which many safety advocates were pushing, according to the agency, “The purpose of the rule is to limit the ability of drivers to work the maximum number of hours currently allowed, or close to the maximum, on a continuing basis to reduce the possibility of driver fatigue. Long daily and weekly hours are associated with an increased risk of crashes and with the chronic health conditions associated with lack of sleep. These changes will affect only the small minority of drivers who regularly work the longer hours.”
The FMCSA is constantly reviewing its rules to improve safety, but without compliance on the part of drivers, the risks remain high, and truck accidents remain a cause of catastrophic highway crashes.
Accidental Death
Wrongful Death Claims
Under old English law where a person’s death was caused by the fault of another person, the claim to recover money damages for the loss died with the victim, and the guilty party had no obligation to compensate the survivors.
In every state, including Maine (and also under modern law in England) the state legislature has enacted laws modifying the old rule and permitting recovery by the survivors in cases where an accidental death is the result of the negligent, careless, intentional or reckless acts of another person.
Most states allow recovery in whatever amount a jury may determine to be fair, but some states, including Maine, place a limit on the amount which the guilty party must pay for the loss of comfort and companionship suffered by the surviving family members. In Maine this amount has been raised from time to time and is currently set at $500,000. There is no limit on recovery for so-called pecuniary losses such as funeral and medical expenses, future loss of financial support and other financial losses due to the death of the victim.
You may be surprised to learn that the surviving spouse is not entitled to the entire amount of whatever is recovered in a wrongful death action unless there are no surviving minor children.
Although the law covering wrongful death cases is not exceptionally complex, these cases do involve some unique considerations, so family members who have lost a loved one will be best served by retaining a law firm with experience in this field.
Wednesday, April 25, 2012
Brain Injury Accidents
Traumatic Brain Injury
A blow to the head, a frequent occurrence in a motor vehicle accident, often results in a concussion and sometimes in a traumatic brain injury (TBI) which can totally or partially incapacitate the victim.
Until now only specialists were trained in the treatment of TBI, and as a result many patients did not receive prompt and appropriate treatment resulting, in some cases, to unnecessary long-term complications and disability.
Now the Obama administration in partnership with U.S. medical schools will begin to include information on the diagnosis and treatment of TBI in their curriculum. So far 105 medical schools and 25 osteopathic colleges have promised to make traumatic brain injury a part of their curriculum.
Suffering a TBI can never be good news, but at least now there may be more hope for light at the end of the tunnel.
Friday, April 20, 2012
Dog Bites
Dog Bite Statistics
According to the Insurance Information Institute it cost insurers $412 million for dog bites in 2009, an increase from $387.2 the previous year, making that five consecutive years of increases. The number of claims, 16,586, was up 4.8 per cent from 2008. Statistically nearly 4.7 million people are bitten by dogs each year, 15 to 20 people are killed and 50% of dog bite fatalities are children under 10 years old. Approximately 100 children are bitten by dogs every day in the U.S. and about 92 of these children will need medical attention.
In a more recent report DogBite.org, a national dog bite victims’ organization devoted to reducing serious dog attacks, presented statistics for 2011 including 31 fatal dog attacks in that year. Of these fatal attacks 67 per cent were by pit bulls even though pit bulls account for only 5 per cent of the total U.S. dog population. Rotweilers accounted for another 13 per cent. Interestingly, somewhat at odds with the Insurance Information Institute’s report, 70 per cent of pit bull victims were between the ages of 32 and 76, and there were 7 cases of pit bulls killing their owners. Texas and California had the highest number of fatal dog attacks.
Although dog bite injuries are small in number compared to motor vehicle accidents, nevertheless the numbers are substantial, and Lowry & Associates has been successful in bringing in fair compensation for many dog bite victims over the years.
Bicycle vs Tractor-trailer
Bicyclist Wrongful Death
Following a seven-day trial in the federal court in New Hampshire, the jury awarded $8.5 million to the family of a bicyclist who was killed in August, 2008, when he was run over by a tractor-trailer on a rural road in Porter, Maine.
The bicyclist was traveling on the right side of the road as he approached a curve to the left. The tractor-trailer, traveling in the same direction, pulled into the left lane to avoid the bicycle, but when confronted with a pickup coming in the opposite direction pulled back to the right to avoid a head-on collision. The bicyclist was forced off the pavement, lost control of his bike, fell back onto the roadway, was run over by the rear tires of the trailer and died instantly.
The jury determined that the driver of the tractor-trailer was negligent in attempting to pass on a curve with insufficient visibility ahead, and rejected the defendant’s claim that it was a safe and reasonable place to pass. The jury also rejected the testimony of the state police accident reconstructionist who said that the main cause of the accident was the condition of the shoulder of the road which caused the decedent to loss control of his bicycle.
The 38-year-old decedent was an experienced bicyclist, a college graduate and owned his own contracting business. At the time of his death he was in excellent health and left a wife and two minor children.
After four hours of deliberation the jury awarded $3.5 million for lost wages and earning capacity and $5 million for loss of consortium for the surviving spouse and children. If the case had been brought in Maine where the accident occurred, the law would have limited the amount of the award for loss of companionship (the legal term is consortium) to only $500,000. The law in New Hampshire appears to have a similar restriction on damages for loss of consortium as Maine, so it is likely that the amount of the award will have to be reduced. The difference between how a jury values loss of a loved one and the limited amount set by the legislature is troubling. I would submit that a jury of ordinary citizens with access to the facts of each case is better equipped to reflect the values of the community than lawmakers sitting in the state capital considering only a theoretical case and responding to the pleas of insurance industry lobbyists.
Death AND Taxes
Tax Time = More Highway Fatalities
I hope that all my readers have survived tax day which fell this year on Tuesday, April 17 due to celebration of Patriots Day in Maine and Massachusetts. It is a bit surprising, but actually makes sense when you think about it, that new research shows that there is an upswing in fatal traffic accidents on tax filing day.
According to a report published in the Journal of the American Medical Association deaths from highway accidents were, on average, 6 percent higher on each of the tax filing days in the last 30 years compared to a day during the week prior and a week later. The study looked at data from the IRS and the NHTSA from 1980 to 2009 and showed that there was an average of 226 fatal crashes for each of the 30 tax days, but only 213 for the 60 control days.
According to Donald Redelmeier, a professor of medicine at the University of Toronto and the lead researcher, the findings suggest that stress, lack of sleep, alcohol use and less tolerance of other drivers contribute to the increase of deaths on tax day. Interestingly Professor Redelmeier noted that an increase of risk of this magnitude is about the same as Super Bowl Sunday, a time notorious for drinking and driving.
Although there has long been speculation that stressful deadlines can contribute to driver error and fatal crashes, this is the first study to confirm that psychological stress contributes to real world accidents.
Everyone agrees that people should observe obvious safety precautions such as buckling up seat belts, obeying the speed limit, avoiding alcohol, minimizing distractions and refraining from driving recklessly, but when people are under stress they frequently forget to do these common sense things.
With tax day just behind us, we have another year to think about being more careful next April 15th.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)